Tesco vs Asda: Which Offers Better Value?

Our comprehensive comparison examines prices, quality, and shopping experience between these retail giants to help you decide where to shop.

Tesco vs Asda at a Glance

Tesco

4.5/5

The UK's largest supermarket chain with extensive product range, strong loyalty program, and multiple store formats.

+3.2% more expensive than Asda

Asda

4.0/5

Value-focused supermarket known for low prices, extensive George clothing range, and large superstore format.

-3.2% cheaper than Tesco

Price Comparison

Based on our analysis of 50 common grocery items, Asda is generally cheaper than Tesco, but the gap varies by product category.

Product Tesco Asda Difference Best Value
Milk (4pt/2.27L) £1.55 £1.50 -3.2% Asda Winner
White Bread (800g) £1.20 £1.15 -4.2% Asda Winner
Eggs (12 Free Range) £2.80 £2.75 -1.8% Asda Winner
Chicken Breast (1kg) £6.50 £6.25 -3.8% Asda Winner
Bananas (per kg) £0.90 £0.87 -3.3% Asda Winner
Tesco/Asda Pasta (500g) £0.59 £0.55 -6.8% Asda Winner
Heinz Beans (415g) £1.15 £1.10 -4.3% Asda Winner
Own Brand Cornflakes (500g) £0.75 £0.68 -9.3% Asda Winner

Overall Price Difference: Asda is approximately 3.2% cheaper than Tesco for a typical basket of goods.

Detailed Comparison

Price & Value

Asda consistently offers lower prices across most product categories, particularly on essentials and own-brand products.

Tesco
7.5/10
Asda
9.0/10

Product Quality

Tesco generally scores higher on product quality, especially for fresh produce, bakery items, and premium ranges.

Tesco
8.5/10
Asda
7.8/10

Store Experience

Tesco offers more convenience with various store formats, while Asda focuses on large superstores with wider aisles.

Tesco
8.2/10
Asda
8.0/10

Loyalty Programs

Tesco Clubcard offers more valuable rewards and partnerships, while Asda Rewards provides more immediate cash savings.

Tesco
9.0/10
Asda
8.0/10

Online Shopping

Both offer strong online platforms, with Tesco having slightly better slot availability and Asda offering competitive delivery prices.

Tesco
8.8/10
Asda
8.5/10

Range & Variety

Tesco offers more premium and specialty ranges, while Asda has strong value offerings and an extensive George clothing range.

Tesco
8.7/10
Asda
8.3/10

The Verdict

While Asda wins on price, Tesco offers better quality, a more sophisticated loyalty program, and greater convenience with its multiple store formats. Your choice ultimately depends on your priorities: if budget is your main concern, Asda is the clear winner; if you value quality, convenience, and rewards, Tesco may be worth the extra cost.

Best for Budget

Asda

Best for Quality

Tesco

Best Loyalty Program

Tesco Clubcard

Most Convenient

Tesco